SJSU Spinning Medicare for All Discussion

Assignment Instructions:

Follow the instructions below to create written talking objective and political points for and against Medicare For All/Universal Health Care/Single Payer Healthcare.

Please read the article to familiarize yourself with the many different proposals for such a system in Congress and in California.
https://www.healthline.com/health/what-medicare-fo…
Specifically:

1. You will write 12 Objective Talking Points (6 in favor, 6 opposed) and 12 Political Talking Points (6 in favor, 6 opposed).
2. You may not cut and paste statements from news sources; they must be in your own words (paraphrase) or you will lose points or receive a 0.
3. Data sources must only be used once (for example, Kaiser Health News, CNN, New York Times, etc., may be used for a data point but one time only).

This original assignment should be cited in APA 7th edition

Specific Requirements: Objective Talking Points, in favor of and opposed to– 12 points total

1.Write 6 objective talking points in favor of Medicare for All/Single Payer/Universal Healthcare. Each talking point must include at least one data source. Include your relevant, scholarly, real (not alternative) facts data source for each talking point.

EXAMPLE:

An example of an objective talking point in favor of Medicare for All (of which you may not use):

Under a Medicare for All plan, cost saving for individual families could decrease significantly because there will no longer be co-pays and high deductible plans and plans would include prescription drug coverage. (Source: https://www.healthline.com/health/what-medicare-for-all-would-look-like-in-america#4)

Write 6 objective talking points opposing Medicare for All/Single Payer/Universal Healthcare. These talking points must include at least one data source. Please include your data source for each talking point as referenced above.

EXAMPLE: Senator Sander’s bill has been estimated to cost at least $32 trillion dollars over the next 10 years. All residents would see their taxes increase to pay for this expenditure. (Source:

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-08-27/medicare-for-all-would-be-costly-for- everyone

Specific Requirements: Political Talking Points – 12 points total

• Write 6 political talking points in favor of Medicare for All.
• Write 6 political talking points opposing Medicare for All. Remember, political talking points need not necessarily be factually correct! Importantly, you must provide a rationale for your political talking points.

Political talking points need not necessarily be factually correct!

Cited data sources required. In this section, you may use other sources of information that are not necessarily fact-based or recognized as such.

In addition, you also need to provide a brief rationale for your political talking points in addition to your talking point.

EXAMPLE (which you may not use):

Political talking point: Medicare for All is a basic human right.

Rationale: Under a Medicare for all system, all residents of the United States, for the first time, will have high quality, comprehensive health insurance. [This rationale is actually highly debatable. But it is an acceptable political rationale because it is true to some.]

EXAMPLE:

Political talking point: Medicare for All/Single Payer undermines one fundamental aspect of America’s values–freedom of choice.

Brief rationale: Medicare for All is a government takeover of health care that undermines the freedom of Americans to control their health and their health care. [Likewise, this rationale is highly debatable. But it is an acceptable political rationale and would be true to some people.]

Assignment grading

The assignment is worth 24 points. Points will be assigned as follows. See Canvas for a more detailed rubric.

• Objective talking points. 12 points, 6 in favor of and 6 opposed?

o Did you address 12 unique, thoughtful,
creative yet serious objective talking points, both for
and against Medicare for All?

o Is each talking point a statement of objective
fact?

o Does each talking point have a relevant and
real fact source (wiki does not count) included?

• Political talking points. 12 points, 6 in favor of and 6 opposed?

o Did you team address 12 unique, thoughtful, creative
yet serious political talking points, both for and
against Medicare for all?

o Do the talking points speak to political
realities for and against Medicare for All?

o Does each talking point
include a thoughtful rationale of the political talking point?