I’m working on a management discussion question and need an explanation and answer to help me learn.

Which of the motivation theories appeals to you the most? You must choose among the following theories (see powerpoint):

Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs

McGregor Theory X and Theory Y

Herzberg Two Factor Motivation-Hygiene Theory

1. Equity Theory (J. Adams)
2. Expectancy Theory (Vroom)
3. a. Which motivation theory makes most sense to you to use when you become a manager (if you are not a supervisor or manager already)? 
4. b. Provide two core reasons why you are choosing this motivation theory.
5. c. Now reflect about your own personal/professional life.  Have you personally experienced increased motivation because of the motivation theory you chose?  Briefly describe this event in your life.  What happened? Mention one way based on which this event increased your motivation.

Motivation – Summary

Define and explain motivation. Motivation is the process by which a person’s efforts are energized, directed, and sustained toward attaining a goal. The energy element is a measure of intensity or drive. The high level of effort needs to be directed in ways that help the organization achieve its goals. Employees must persist in putting forth effort to achieve those goals.

Compare and contrast early theories of motivation. Individuals move up the hierarchy of five needs (physiological, safety, social, esteem, and self-actualization) as needs are substantially satisfied. A need that’s substantially satisfied no longer motivates. A Theory X manager believes that people don’t like to work or won’t seek out responsibility so they have to be threatened and coerced to work. A Theory Y manager assumes that people like to work and seek out responsibility, so they will exercise self-motivation and self-direction. Herzberg’s theory proposed that intrinsic factors associated with job satisfaction were what motivated people. Extrinsic factors associated with job dissatisfaction simply kept people from being dissatisfied. Three-needs theory proposed three acquired needs that are major motives in work: need for achievement, need for affiliation, and need for power.

Compare and contrast contemporary theories of motivation. Goal-setting theory says that specific goals increase performance and difficult goals, when accepted; result in higher performance than do easy goals. Important points in goal-setting theory include intention to work toward a goal as a major source of job motivation; specific hard goals to produce higher levels of output than generalized goals; participation in setting goals is probably preferable to assigning goals, but not always; feedback guides and motivates behavior, especially self-generated feedback; and contingencies that affect goal setting include goal commitment, self-efficacy, and national culture.

The job characteristics model says there are five core job dimensions (skill variety, task identity, task significance, autonomy, and feedback) that are used to design motivating jobs. Equity theory focuses on how employees compare their inputs-outcomes ratios to relevant others’ ratios. A perception of inequity will cause an employee to do something about it. Procedural justice has a greater influence on employee satisfaction than does distributive justice. Expectancy theory says that an individual tends to act in a certain way based on the expectation that the act will be followed by a desired outcome. Expectancy is the effort-performance linkage (how much effort do I need to exert to achieve a certain level of performance); instrumentality is the performance-reward linkage (achieving at a certain level of performance will get me what reward); and valence is the attractiveness of the reward (is the reward what I want).

Discuss current issues in motivating employees. During rough economic conditions, managers must look for creative ways to keep employees’ efforts energized, directed, and sustained toward achieving goals. Most motivational theories were developed in the United States and have a North American bias. Some theories (Maslow’s need hierarchy, achievement need, and equity theory) don’t work well for other cultures. However, the desire for interesting work seems important to all workers and Herzberg’s motivator (intrinsic) factors may be universal. Managers face challenges in motivating unique groups of workers. A diverse workforce is looking for flexibility. Professionals want job challenge and support, and are motivated by the work itself. Contingent workers want the opportunity to become permanent or to receive skills training. Open-book management is when financial statements (the books) are shared with employees who have been taught what that information means. Employee recognition programs consist of personal attention, approval, and appreciation for a job well done. Pay-for-performance programs are variable compensation plans that pay employees on the basis of some performance measure.